Sarah Paulson and Lupita Nyong’o are both Taylor Swift fans

So, guess which actors turned into certified Taylor Swift fans? It’s Sarah Paulson and Lupita Nyong’o. “The American Horror Story” and “Black Panther” superstars officially began their Swifities era after having a blast at Taylor Swift’s “Eras Tour” in Los Angeles.

In case you need proof, Sarah sat down with PEOPLE to talk about how “starstruck” she felt seeing the spectacular show the “Blank Space” pop queen served. The Emmy-winning icon, joined by the stunning Lupita, didn’t start off as hardcore Swifties, but couldn’t help but be totally blown away by that Tay-Tay magic in the concert:

“We got to be on the floor, and someone from her team came out and handed Lupita and me a bag of merchandise. They said to me, “This is from Taylor.” I was like, ‘I think I’m going to faint.’” she said.

Post-concert, Lupita shared some of the cutest Instagram snaps of their “Eras” night. The iconic Sarah and Lupia duo took some pics with Zach Braff, Donald Faison, and Darren Criss, proving they surely had a blast that night. Lupita even thanked Swifties for the suggestions they made to her friend group to exchange the bracelets they were given at the show.

Tay’s tour recently kicked off again in Latin America. After a three-month break, the hitmaker decided to get back on the road and resumed her dazzling concerts. Last week, she wrapped up her 3 sold-out shows in Buenos Aires and is currently heading to Brazil. Taylor Swift will be performing for thousands of people in Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo.